Current Member for over 2 months (at the time of review).
Pros:
-Some decent videos if you can find them
-Some exclusive content again if you can find it
-Bonus site to BrokeStraightBoys so it doesn't cost anything to join
Cons:
-Difficult to navigate the site
-mostly consisting of VHS movies of lore these days
Bottom Line:
Another brief review of a bonus site for BrokeStraightBoys. I remember being a member of HS Boys when it created its own content many years ago. They stopped doing that and rely on others' older content as well as VHS movies of lore. (Remember going to the adult book stores and browsing the VHS section?)
There are some videos of decent quality to be found on this site. It's where to look that can be a bit interesting. At least I didn't shell any money out for this as I would be quite upset.
The bottom line is customers should never join a site because they offer bonus sites or content. Most of the additional stuff is crap or older videos most other sites use as their bonus site/content.
The idea is many think they are getting a huge deal when the fact is these former sites have long run their course. Buy a membership for the site you want, not its bonus content.
-Original content with exclusive models
-One of the bonus sites for BrokeStraightBoys
Cons:
-The site has not updated in over eight years
-The videos are of low quality
-Difficulty navigating site and downloading videos
-most of the videos are corrupted in download
Bottom Line:
This is going to be a brief review as this site is a bonus site for BrokeStraightBoys. It has not updated in over eight years and the videos are rather old and low res quality.
The site has a vintage feel to it from the days when porn was starting out. The videos can be downloaded in parts as was normal back in the day. Now we download video file sizes which are larger than a dozen or so of these older videos.
The models are nice looking and it is a solo site but features duos as well as a few trios. They do the usual which is still done today. Nothing has changed when it comes to doing porn videos.
If this were a lone site, I would say skip it. However, it comes with BrokeStraightBoys so it is worth a look in that regard.
Bottom line, if the owners of this site wanted to they could update this and make it one of the better sites out there content wise.
Edited to add: Most of the videos are so corrupted they are very scrambled when trying to view them. This is probably because the site has no one doing any type of maintenance on it.
Current Member for over 2 months (at the time of review).
Pros:
-Original content
-Some hot models
-Still updates once a week
-Bonus site to Broke College Boys
-Over 600 videos
Cons:
-Most videos contain fugly models
-Many contain old men fondling younger models (old man's hand syndrome)
-Many videos are two parters
-Daily Download limits
Bottom Line:
College Boy Physicals is a site that is part of what you get when you join Broke Straight Boys. It is actually quite decent as far as bonus sites go. The videos are decent enough (and there are over 600 videos on the site alone) with the models being quite good looking.
It is not a perfect site as many videos contain fugly models as well as older men (50+) playing doctor on younger models. This can be a turn-off to some (me included and I'm over 50) as it is a bit creepy.
The site updates once a week with new videos (they don't recycle which is always good) featuring many models from Broke Straight Boys plus other sites.
Some of the 'College Boys' are in their 30s which pushes the definition of college age. Still, they usually are good looking enough to make one forgive the site.
This is a niche site as it involves young men getting a physical as the site title denotes. There is no graphic examinations other than a finger being inserted here and there. Some models are masturbated while most others engage in oral sex with the 'doctor'. Pretty much all the videos take place at the same set of a doctor's office.
The quality of the videos are quite good with over 600 videos in the catalog. Add to that the many hundreds of videos on BSBs and this is a true bargain. Some of the videos are two parters which I feel could have been combined to make one video. Then again, they are updating once a week so they must do what they must do.
$15 a month gets you both sites and that includes downloading. Very good bargain for these sites. I don't know if I would join this site if it wasn't included in the BSB package although I would slightly recommend it if it was a one time deal.
Updated to up the rating as I did give it a bit of a low score because of its niche site quality.
Current Member for over 1 month (at the time of review).
Pros:
-Exclusive content and models
-Over 1100 videos
-Low cost of $14.87 a month including downloads
Cons:
-Daily download limit
-No more solo videos
-The age of many of the models is around 30, not quite college age.
-Photo sets are of differing quality and quantity
Bottom Line:
There are some gems of videos hidden in this rather large site. This site is owned by the same who own BrokeStraightBoys and BoyGusher. The site has had its ups and downs like the other sites listed. While the other sites are much improved, CollegeDudes seems to be doing rather so-so.
It isn't a bad site mind you. It has many hot models and with over 1100 videos there is bound to be something for everyone to like. The site now updates once a week.
I guess it comes down to the latest models. While there are some real cuties out there, the latest batches are homely and that is being kind. Not sure why that is for this site.
They also tend to use the same models over and over again. Not always a bad thing but one likes variety. They are moving away from that which is a good thing.
The owners of these sites like to have download limits. I would really hate it if the file sizes were in the gigabytes like many other sites. That would make it so only a handful of videos can be downloaded.
The main thing going for this site is how cheap it is to join at $14.87 a month. Many won't feel cheated at joining for a few months at that price. They can find plenty of decent videos and much to like about the site.
I do hope the people who run this site will get back to college aged men. That is what we are looking for and want out of this site. Still, this site is worth recommending.
Also included is BoyGusher as a bonus site plus a few others which aren't so good.
Current Member for over 2 months (at the time of review).
Pros:
-Original and exclusive content and models
-Over 1600 videos
-Low cost site at $14.87 a month including downloads
-Updates three times a week
Cons:
-Daily download limit
-the site can experience periods of lower quality models and output
Bottom Line:
I have not been to this site in a long time and decided to review it again. It has improved quite a bit as the last time it appeared the site was losing its unique appeal. I am proud to say it is back and better than ever.
The site is cheaper than most other pay sites at only $14.87 a month including downloads. There is a daily download limit which is offset by the videos not having huge file sizes. The quality of the latest videos is quite good as I can watch them on my large flat screen television.
The models themselves range from quite hot to rather typical blokes. Most are supposedly straight who are there only for the cash and are willing to do more for extra money. Like other sites, they appear to know what they are doing for only being straight. I would guess most of these boys have fooled around with a buddy or two.
Navigating the site is quite easy to find models and videos according to date or popularity. There are over 1600 videos on this site of exclusive content. Add to that 100+ videos on the Behind the Scenes pages and one has plenty to view on this site.
There are also bonus sites including BoyGusher which is easy to get at on this site. There are over 480 more exclusive videos to add with no extra cost.
In an era of rising costs for sites (most now charge $29.95 a month or more), it is refreshing to find a very good site at such a low price. They don't post videos from other companies but their own content which makes it even better.
I do like this site and am glad to see the owners busting their buns to keep it in such good shape. Kudos to them for listening to us customers.
Current Member for over 2 months (at the time of review).
Pros:
-Exclusive content
-low cost site
-HD videos
-exclusive models
Cons:
-Daily download limit
-Many videos have an older man masturbating the younger models which can be a turn-off for some
-Low quality photo sets for the most part
Bottom Line:
BoyGusher is one of those sites which is included when one joins CollegeDudes. It costs only $14.87 a month which is a very good deal. The site is rather basic and has mostly videos to view or download. There are some photo sets but most are just screenshots.
Most of the newer videos are in HD with the older ones being of lesser quality. There are more than 480 videos on the site. Updates are once a week.
A problem with the site is how to get to it if one joins CollegeDudes. One has to go to many of the other poorer quality bonus sites to find it. I wonder how many of those customers can find this little gem of a site. The good news is BrokeStraightBoys has this site as a bonus site listed at the top of the page.
The boys for the most part are youthful with some older ones thrown in. They are all presented as 'straight' which some of the videos cast doubts on. Many are downright hotties which makes for joining this site alone worth it.
One of the few downsides is the creepy old man's hand videos where an older man masturbates the younger models. I have never liked this when it is used on other sites. It feels as if the boys are being taken advantage of even though they are paid for it. Quite a turn off to an otherwise good site. More than a third of the videos has this which makes the site lose points.
There also is a daily download limit but the video file sizes are not that high so one is able to download about 12-15 a day.
The videos also consist of duos with hot models supposedly having their first gay experience. We like the fantasy even though we know better. As I have stated for other such sites, I believe most of the boys have fooled around before with a buddy or two.
As sites decline in this era of megasites, BoyGusher is a breath of fresh air. Sure, it doesn't have all the bells and whistles of other sites, but the cost alone and content more than make up for it.
Was a member approx. 4 months prior to this review.
Pros:
-later videos in HD
-many videos in inventory
Cons:
-download limit
-lack of solo videos which made the company special
-sub par models
-photosets not of good quality
Bottom Line:
This is one of those sites which started out fair and then improved greatly. After a few years, it started to change and not for the better.
The main problem is the site is now sex videos of two guys. There is nothing wrong with that as I love duo scenes but where are the solos of the models? I do like the older videos where the boys talk a bit and then show us the goods.
I think this is done to save money as most want just duo videos these days. However, the site is called college dudes for a reason. It looks like any other site out there these days.
Some of the newer models are cute, but many are average. They also keep models who are well past their primes. Some do like older models and that is fine. I just don't expect many on a site called college dudes.
Recommended for the older videos.
Updated November 2016: It seems they are going with older and more homely models of late. Too bad as this was a decent site at one time.
Was a member approx. 5 months prior to this review.
Pros:
-large number of videos available
-many exclusive models
-high quality videos in HD
-decent price for what you get
-decent bonus video area
Cons:
-photosets are of subpar quality
-the site itself is changing from amateur to produced porn
-repetition of the models in videos
-only one new model a month for the most part
-quality of the later models has taken a downturn
Bottom Line:
This is one of those sites where I have to ask "What happened?" It was one of the go to sites for amateur porn and now it is all changing. I can see why a site owner wants to changes things up, but there is a reason why the name is Broke Straight Boys.
The biggest change is the use of the same models over and over again for the updates. If someone were to join now, they would find themselves frustrated as there are no real new models. They would also wonder about the quality of who is appearing before the camera as well.
I admit, I love the older stuff on this site. The models actually were what the title states: Straight boys who are broke and in need of some quick cash. They also were better looking and much sexier.
Maybe the site will go back to its roots in the future. If not, we still have the older stuff.
I forgot to mention the bonus videos for members are an added plus. Most come from Boys First Time (older stuff).
Updated November 2016: Another site which has gone from young men to older men who are not very good looking. Not sure if there are too many sites these days or what. The older videos are still worth it.
Current Member for less than 1 month (at the time of review).
Pros:
Lots of videos. Generally believable execution of premise. Range of different types of guys shown.
Cons:
Undisclosed daily download limit of 5GB. Once limit exceeded, they lock your account for a minimum of 24 hours. This should be disclosed prominently so customer can decide whether this is something they wish to support.
Bottom Line:
I will end up dropping my subscription at the end of the term because of the daily download limit non-disclosure. I feel this is as dishonest as not disclosing DRM, limited trial access, and other "gotchas." I just won't do business with dishonest websites.
*Newbie reviews and ratings don't count toward a site's overall score/rank until the user reaches the Rookie status level (5 points). This rule is needed to help prevent fake (or heavily biased) profiles and reviews.
Protecting Minors We are strong supporters of RTA and ICRA, two of the most recognized self labeling organizations. Our site is properly labeled to assist in the protection of minors accessing inappopriate content. For information about filtering tools, check this site.
DISCLAIMER: ALL MODELS APPEARING ON THIS WEBSITE ARE 18 YEARS OR OLDER.
To report child pornography, go directly to ASACP! We're proud to be a corporate sponsor.
Have concerns or questions about porn addiction? We recommend this helpful resource.
