| Msg # |
User |
Message |
Date |
1
|
messmer (Disabled)
|
Well, it certainly wasn't a top rated site with me, Denner. Not that they did anything wrong it was simply as far removed from my taste as one could get.
|
07-15-12 10:01am
Reply To Message
|
2
|
pat362 (0)
|
Don't forget that it's top rated only because the default is minimum 2 reviews in the last 90 days. If you change the parameter to 3 or more reviews than the site disapears completely from the list.
I'm glad that a site which seems to have such great content gets a high score but 2 reviews will not necessarily mean that it's better than a site with 10 reviews with a lower average score. There are some sites that cater to a more selective type of customer so that those that join and review it are less likely to be disapointed and therefore are more likely to give a high score.
|
07-15-12 10:14am
Reply To Message
|
3
|
exotics4me (0)
|
Denner, I don't think the amount of reviews is right. ATK Galleria made some changes around the first of the year and I think it reset their old reviews. If you notice on the TBP facts it's first listed in December 2011. Galleria has been around, I think, since around 2001. Whatever change went into effect in December 2011 has created a new page or caused the old reviews to no longer apply to it. It's pretty confusing really. This is my guess though it may be wrong. ATK launched the ATK Network, which has Galleria, Exotics, Hairy, Archives and Petites all in one package. My guess is that since it has Archives, they removed the old content from Galleria and filled the Archive site with it. Maybe since they did that, it makes ATK Galleria a "new" site since they seemed to have removed nearly all of the old low-quality content from it.
|
07-15-12 01:36pm
Reply To Message
|
4
|
Drooler (Disabled)
|
It's top rated at "TBAD" (The Best According to Drooler, LOL), and by some coincidence it's up there in the more "official" rankings.
I don't think there's a site I've rejoined more often, actually. I guess it's just my cup 'o tea. With the improvements over the past year or so, it's a top favorite.
But that's just me. Preferences do vary amongst the PUers.
|
07-15-12 02:11pm
Reply To Message
|
5
|
tangub (0)
|
You'll have to excuse me if I'm appearing a bit thick here but what is the point you're making in this comment? Are you implying that ATK Galleria doesn't deserve to be a high ranked site? Are you questioning the sincerity of the recent reviews that make it the top ranked site? Just because you may not rate the site highly doesn't mean others are not entitled to do so.
|
07-15-12 02:32pm
Reply To Message
|
6
|
elephant (0)
|
Am I right in thinking you don't get all the other atk sites when you join one. I've seen there is some really good Zoe Kush stuff on these sites.
|
07-15-12 04:01pm
Reply To Message
|
7
|
Claypaws (Suspended)
|
REPLY TO #6 - elephant :
Yes, you are right. You only get the site you join. But, if a model is "petite" and she is on ATK Petites, then you get all her content on all sites by joining just ATK Petites. Zoey Kush is on ATK Petites. So joining ATK Petites gives you access to all of her stuff on the whole ATK Network. That currently stands at 102 photo series and 42 movies. How much do you like Zoey Kush?
|
07-15-12 05:31pm
Reply To Message
|
8
|
PinkPanther (0)
|
REPLY TO #3 - exotics4me :
I think this is right as to what happened. I noticed that it was odd at one point that there was a drastic drop-off in feedback (comments and reviews) on this site, but didn't investigate as to why.
I DO regard this is a top site - in terms of quantity and sometimes in terms of quality, definitely in terms of doing what they do every day.
|
07-15-12 08:09pm
Reply To Message
|
9
|
Capn (0)
|
I think it is down to the consistency of the high score.
More reviews might well lower it.
Cap'n. :0)
|
07-16-12 11:13am
Reply To Message
|
10
|
elephant (0)
|
REPLY TO #7 - Claypaws :
Thanks for this Claypaws
Now this does sound maybe worth it for me then after all, yeah I'm a massive Zoey fan, if only they had more Zoeys in American porn I'd be a happy bunny, she is perfection.
|
07-17-12 09:11am
Reply To Message
|
11
|
Claypaws (Suspended)
|
"...with only two reviews."
That is the key. Top Recent sites refers only to sites reviewed in the last 90 days and only needs at least 2 reviews. If you display all top sites and alter the dropdown to "all time" it moves to position 7. If you increase the number of required reviews to 3, it drops off the list completely.
In general, you get very different lists if you play around with time frame and number of reviews.
|
07-18-12 07:50am
Reply To Message
|
12
|
Claypaws (Suspended)
|
REPLY TO #2 - pat362 :
Woops. Sorry pat362. I just noticed you already said exactly what I just have regarding the 2 reviews criterion.
|
07-18-12 08:22am
Reply To Message
|
13
|
pat362 (0)
|
REPLY TO #12 - Claypaws :
Nothing wrong with two people saying the same thing. This way the lazy people who prefer to read comments from the bottyom up will get your reply first.
|
07-18-12 06:27pm
Reply To Message
|
