| Type |
Site - Score |
Feedback / Review |
Date |
Review
26
|
Dirty Jason
(0)
72.0
|
| Status: |
Current Member for less than 1 month (at the time of review).
|
| Pros: |
Decent start for an amateur porn producer
Girls are decent looking |
| Cons: |
Expensive - $34.95
limited selection of girls - 15 as of now
Only average quality video
Most girls do not look or act like amateurs. |
| Bottom Line: |
Here is the premise: A pudgy farm boy from Texas (think Hoss Cartright's little brother) decides to film his dates without their knowledge. He lures the girls back to his apartment and then proceeds with a lengthy seduction ending most times in sex. There are two big problems I see with this site. First, many of the girls do not look or act like dates. In fact, many are familiar faces seen on other websites, so I am assuming everything is staged. The other big problem is the price. You pay $34.95 for only 15 girls. Here is how I got snookered. I joined a much better website "Exploited College Teens" and there was fineprint at the bottom of the signup screen which asked if I wanted to join Dirty Jason for $34.95. I thought it meant $34.95 for both sites, but it was actually $34.95 extra. In any case, the site is worth a look if you can get it for $3.95 on a trial basis. Otherwise, I advise you to pass this one up until the selection increases and the price declines. |
|
10-08-07 02:22pm
Replies (9)
|
Review
27
|
Mouth Target
(0)
78.0
|
| Status: |
Was a member approx. 4 months prior to this review.
|
| Pros: |
Cute girl next door types. Some seen before on "Exploited Teens" partner site.
Regular updates (At least there was when I joined) |
| Cons: |
Only average video quality
Newer site with limited selection of videos at this time.
No way to view all past updates which is key to determining if you want to join or rejoin. |
| Bottom Line: |
If you like "Exploited Teens", this site gives you more of some of the same girls in a different setting and a different guy behind the camera. The real achilles heel of this site right now is that it does not offer a way to view past updates. Before rejoining I would want to see a list of the updates which have occurred since I last was a member. |
|
09-12-07 02:15am
Replies (0)
|
Comment
28
|
Exploited Teens
(0)
|
|
09-02-07 11:07pm
Replies (2)
|
Comment
29
|
So Cal Coeds
(0)
|
|
09-02-07 10:59pm
Replies (0)
|
Reply
30
|
ATK Premium
(0)
|
Reply of
exotics4me's Reply
I think ATK is based out of Florida. These guys used to be the kings of
girl next door American amateurs. However, in the past few years it looks like they decided to focus more on the European types. I'm guessing those Eastern European girls work very cheaply. The problem with the European girls is they all look the same. I'm guessing they are real professional models who can't find work elsewhere. If you check out the exagerated poses you know what I mean. The photo and video equipment also appears to be lower then that used for the U.S. girls also.
|
07-02-07 12:47pm
|
Review
31
|
ATK Premium
(0)
81.0
|
| Status: |
Current Member for less than 1 month (at the time of review).
|
| Pros: |
Good selection of models (Mostly European) many seen before on ATK's other sites
Written Biographies for each model with hobbies, likes, dislikes etc..
Offers MOV and WMV format videos |
| Cons: |
Photo quality and size does not justify "Premium" label.
Video quality is only average by todays standards.
Should offer HDV to justify premium label.
Many of the models are not attractive enough to be included on a supposed "Premium" ATK site.
Too little depth provided for each model. |
| Bottom Line: |
When I first subscribed to ATK premium a few years back, I was impressed at the concept. Take ATK's best models (Josie, Karen, Kimber etc..) were the first examples), and feature them on a website which allows the subscriber to get to know each of them much more in depth. Similar to what FTV girls is doing now. In addition, the photography and video quality was a cut above that found on the standard ATK sites. Coming back to revisit this site after a few years is a shock. There are now many more girls, but it clearly a case of increased quantity and decreased quality. The majority of girls do not belong on so called "Premium" site. Photo quality is no better then ATK's other sites (1536 X 1024) and video quality for the latest movie update was only 640 X 480 for both WMV and MOV formats. By todays standards, you need to offer HDV video and large format photos for a regular site just to keep up with the competition. Another gripe I have is that background info for most models now includes just a written biography and thats it. In summary, I think this site needs a total rework in all areas just to justify being called "Premium". Very disappointing!!! |
|
07-02-07 04:16am
Replies (4)
|
Reply
32
|
Ron Harris
(0)
|
Reply of
nygiants03's Review
Regarding the quality of the HV videos, I consider the HV MOV files featured on the Simonscans website to be significantly superior to those found on Ron Harris.
|
06-28-07 04:40pm
|
Review
33
|
Ron Harris
(0)
72.0
|
| Status: |
Current Member for less than 1 month (at the time of review).
|
| Pros: |
Professional skill of photographer
Worth a look for fans of the Babe look and glamour photography.
Monthly membership fee is more reasonable then other sites. |
| Cons: |
Sets are way too small.
The voice of the photographer is quite annoying in the videos. He sounds like a dirty old man.
Most of the girls are not new faces. |
| Bottom Line: |
I have to say I was quite disappointed in this website. For all the hype, there is just not that much beef. First of all, the sets are way too small. You get some high definition videos of the girls, but I was not impressed with those either. The guy filming the action, I'm assuming it was Ron Harris, sounded pretty course and obnoxious in the way he conversed with the girls during each shoot. In addition, the girls just look a little too made up for my taste. However, if you are a fan of the Babe look, maybe this site might interest you. The only reason I joined was because of the reasonable $20 fee. However, if given a chance to do it over, I would not join again. |
|
06-28-07 06:04am
Replies (0)
|
Review
34
|
ATK Archives
(0)
85.0
|
| Status: |
Was a member approx. 2 months prior to this review.
|
| Pros: |
Excellent photography (Newer sets), Older sets reflect technology available at the time.
Huge selection of girls
Excellent value for the money.
Very good navigation
Sets featured here are no longer available on ATK's main websites. |
| Cons: |
Quality of web videos looks increasingly outdated by todays standards. |
| Bottom Line: |
Just a few years ago ATK Galleria and ATK Hairy were two of the best amateur sites out there. These sites featured a huge selection of mostly American girl next door amateurs. However, in recent years the use of European babe types has increased dramatically. Finding a real amateur American girl on these sites is now more of an exception then a rule. Anyway, if you have never seen the old ATK websites, the ATK archives is a treasure trove of the type of material that made ATK famous. Even if you previously visited the older ATK sites, you might want to revisit the Archives to see some of your old favorites.
I will admit, some of the older material from the late 90's does look a bit primitive compared to today's technology, but they are still worth viewing and you can see the improvement in quality as you move forward through the years. I highly recommend this site. |
|
06-28-07 05:22am
Replies (0)
|
Comment
35
|
abbywinters
(0)
|
|
06-26-07 11:25am
Replies (1)
|
Comment
36
|
AT Kingdom
(0)
|
|
06-26-07 11:19am
Replies (0)
|
Reply
37
|
N/A
|
Reply of
nygiants03's Poll
I also think that newer sites should have reduced rates until the content is built up to the point it is worth the standard 29.95 per month charge demanded by established quality sites.
|
06-26-07 11:12am
|
Review
38
|
Nubiles.net
(0)
87.0
|
| Status: |
Current Member for less than 1 month (at the time of review).
|
| Pros: |
Great selection of cute amateurs. Some not seen on other sites.
Excellent video quality - Some HDV
Very fast download times for videos
Excellent navigation tools
Photos are very good quality and include a slide show function.
Good value |
| Cons: |
Extensive use of European girls to enhance selection. Videos of these girls are lesser in quality then the girls of the USA.
The large format selection feature for photos is somewhat cumbersome to use. |
| Bottom Line: |
This is a very nice find. Many of the girls you have seen elsewhere, but here you can see them in some great looking videos. One of the guys who shoots the videos also does work for Karups Hometown. However his videos look better here. I found the AVI files looked the best for non HDV. I I was also impressed by the navigation tools. You can tell there was a lot of work put into this component. the photos are very good quality, but the videos are the star attraction for this website. |
|
06-15-07 04:33pm
Replies (0)
|
Review
39
|
Suburban Amateurs
(0)
85.0
|
| Status: |
Current Member for less than 1 month (at the time of review).
|
| Pros: |
Large collection of cute British amateurs
Absolutely huge photo sets
Emphasis on Lingerie
Photos are sharp and color balance is very natural looking. |
| Cons: |
Photos are medium size only
Videos quality needs improvement
Videos detract from the wholesome girl next door impression given by the photo shoots.
Extra bonus websites such as one eyed jack and UK Amateurs are mediocre quality. |
| Bottom Line: |
This is one of the two best British Amateur websites out there. Simonscans being the other. In some ways Suburban Amateurs exceeds Simonscans because the girls here just look more like amateurs and the color balance of the photography is much more natural. Simonscans tends to look overly warm and red and his models look more professional looking. One thing I really love about Suburban Amateurs is the emphasis on lingerie modeling. Each of the girls seems to have at least one lingerie set where they start fully clothed and then peel off the layers in a sexy fashion. The sets themselves are larger then anything I have ever seen. The real achilles heel for this site for me was the videos. You really want the video to serve as a teaser or enhancement of the amateur quality of the photoshoot. However in this case the girls are asked to act and talk like low class sluts which completely detroys the impression formed by the photoshoots. I still recommend this site highly, but I strongly recommend you avoid the videos. |
|
06-09-07 05:31am
Replies (0)
|
Comment
40
|
Exploited Teens
(0)
|
|
05-13-07 05:40am
Replies (0)
|
Review
41
|
Girls Out West
(0)
75.0
|
| Status: |
Current Member for less than 1 month (at the time of review).
|
| Pros: |
Consider this site a poor relative of Abby Winters. Some of the great looking girls found on Abby Winters are also featured here. The site features both photos and movies which are updated on a regular basis.
Cost for a month membership is reasonable a reasonable $20. |
| Cons: |
Photo quality is mediocre by todays standards
Video quality is mediocre by todays standards
Many of the girls are unattractive. |
| Bottom Line: |
If you like Abby Winters, this site might be worth checking out to see more of the same girls in a different setting. However, be warned many of the girls are not as attractive as those found on Abby Winters. In addition, you might be disappointed at the mediocre photo and video quality. However, for $20 I think it is worth a shot because there are some real gems here.
Follow-Up:
I rejoined the site recently and was disappointed to find no real improvements to note. Video is still noticeably inferior by todays standards and most of the girls would still never make it on Abby Winters. One of the more popular recurring models from Abby (Paula) appears in some videos packing on quite a bit of extra baggage in the rear and thighs. I'm leaning towards giving this site a thumbs down recommendation for membership. |
|
05-13-07 05:36am
Replies (0)
|
Review
42
|
Donny's Girls
(0)
80.0
|
| Status: |
Was a member approx. 4 months prior to this review.
|
| Pros: |
Photography by the sites founder (Donavan Philips) is top notch. Very sharp photos, with natural skin colors. Girls for the most part were attractive girl next door types. Detailed biographies of the models added depth and character to the photos. |
| Cons: |
The sites founder appears to have left the porn business. Site is still updated regularly, but much of the "newer" material is just technically enhanced older stuff. The actual new material is not up to the standards set by the sites founder. To be specific, the girls are not as attractive and lack the girl next door quality which made the site a success in the beginning. |
| Bottom Line: |
A mixed bag. Recommended for an initial subscription to view the top notch photography and fresh faced amateurs featured by the sites founder. Not recommended for subsequent subscription due to the
lower quality of the sites new operators. |
|
04-30-07 04:43am
Replies (0)
|
Review
43
|
Karup's Hometown Amateurs
(0)
94.0
|
| Status: |
Was a member approx. 3 months prior to this review.
|
| Pros: |
Tons of down home American girl next door types (Karups uses it's sister site for showcasing the Eastern European talent). Very high quality of photos. Outstanding color accuracy (Skin colors are true to life and natural).
Video interviews to allow you to get to know the model. The video quality is very much improved from a few years ago and is excellent by todays standards. Updates virtually every day. Dating of updates allows you to easily pick up where you left off when resubscribing. |
| Cons: |
None |
| Bottom Line: |
One of the top Amateur sites on the net for down home American girl next door types. Photos and Videos are top notch! |
|
04-30-07 12:25am
Replies (0)
|
Review
44
|
Sapphic Erotica
(0)
80.0
|
| Status: |
Was a member approx. 4 months prior to this review.
|
| Pros: |
High Quality of of videos (Recent only)
Almost exclusive use of European Model types (If that is what you prefer)
Tons of content with regular updates
Tons of Hot Lesbian Content. Many featuring three or more girls. |
| Cons: |
If you don't like Eastern European model types, look elsewhere. This site is not for you. I personally found the site to be pretty boring. |
| Bottom Line: |
Strictly for fans of Eastern European model types.
In my opinion this site is over rated by many of the
professional reviewers. |
|
04-29-07 02:31am
Replies (0)
|
Review
45
|
FTV Girls
(0)
90.0
|
| Status: |
Was a member approx. 2 months prior to this review.
|
| Pros: |
Videos let you get to know the girls by following them around town doing normal activities and talking about themselves.
Video quality has improved considerably over the last year.
Large selection of girls, many never before seen.
Lots of graphic closeups and extended masturbation scenes. |
| Cons: |
Some of the girls have appeared on other sites.
Photo shoots are uninspiring.
Could use more girl girl scenes.
Navigation is somewhat cumbersome |
| Bottom Line: |
Well worth the price of admission. If you have not been to the site in a while, it is worth revisiting for the improved video quality. This really makes a huge difference. |
|
04-21-07 01:39am
Replies (0)
|
Review
46
|
Amateur Allure
(0)
84.0
|
| Status: |
Current Member for less than 1 month (at the time of review).
|
| Pros: |
Lots of horny girl next door types. Many not seen elsewhere.
Very similar to Rodney Moore in style.
Regular updates and interesting and unusually personal Blog.
Recent upgrade in quality of videos - Windows Media Files now supported although quality is similar to the Mov files. Full movie files are also now supported, where before you could only get small clips.
The download times are very fast. |
| Cons: |
The videos are done with an annoying fisheye type lens.
Video quality could use further improvement.
Photos are below average quality (By todays standards) |
| Bottom Line: |
Not bad. One of the better amateur sites out there for videos of never before seen girl next door types. The score would improve considerably if Thomas were to ditch the fisheye lens and provide HD quality full video files of current and past models.
See Simons Scans for an example of how to do this. |
|
03-28-07 06:12am
Replies (2)
|
Review
47
|
Rookie Babe
(0)
85.0
|
| Status: |
Was a member approx. 1 month prior to this review.
|
| Pros: |
One of the best selections on the net for girl next door amateur's.
The video interview section lets you get to know a little about each one in their own words. |
| Cons: |
Videos are streaming only and not very large.
Photo quality is just okay.
The girls do get naked, but the poses are all softcore. |
| Bottom Line: |
Outstanding selection of girls, however the site needs a huge amount of technical upgrade work. Great potential though. |
|
03-22-07 03:13am
Replies (0)
|
Reply
48
|
abbywinters
(0)
|
Reply of
mudman's Reply
Okay, maybe nobody really merits a 100%, but to me these reviews are subjective and serve as a consumer guide to potential users. The 100% is a curved grade which represents my opinion of how the site fares in comparison with all other amateur sites I have seen. Since Abby Winters is cutting edge, and appears to be so superior overall to anything else out there, this is my way of representing this site as reference standard for the amateur niche. If I were to pick one area where another site has surpassed Abby, and this was very recent, I would pick Simons Scans because they upgraded their videos to include the MOV format option coded in H.264.
|
03-14-07 11:23pm
|
Review
49
|
abbywinters
(0)
100.0
|
| Status: |
Current Member for over 1 year (at the time of review).
|
| Pros: |
This is the only true 100 on the net right now. Abby Winters is in a league by herself. This site has it all. Tons of gorgeous, natural, girl next door Australian girls, and some visitors from other countries as well; beautiful photography, great quality videos, an outstanding forum, regular updates, outstanding girl girl scenes that blow away anything else on the net; a demonstrated commitment and enviable track record for continuous quality improvement; and lastly a great price. WOW! |
| Cons: |
None |
| Bottom Line: |
Abby Winters reigns supreme as the top amateur site on the net right now. Nothing else comes close! |
|
03-14-07 03:08am
Replies (9)
|
Review
50
|
Exploited Teens
(0)
95.0
|
| Status: |
Was a member approx. 3 months prior to this review.
|
| Pros: |
Probably the best site on the net right now for viewing videos of genuine girl next door college type girls. These girls really look and sound as if they just stepped off a college campus. How this guy gets these type of girls to do what they do, and appear to enjoy it also, is a wonder to me. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED! |
| Cons: |
Unfortunately the quality of the video does not match the quality of the girls. The video only appears sharp and clear in a small Quicktime window.
No photos. Video only. |
| Bottom Line: |
One of the top amateur sites on the net. If you like girl next door college girl types, this is the best out there for videos.
Follow-Up:
I just rejoined the site and there is a major change to report. It seems "Mike" decided to discontinue offering High Definition format videos after just 3
episodes. All of the newer videos are the same as before. The good news is there is no change in the quality of girls "Mike" is getting to do these videos. They are still as cute as ever. |
|
03-07-07 04:42pm
Replies (0)
|
